Negative Yoga experience: Please Help

Such an old thread this is!

While many in the west have lost sight of true yoga, there are little gems out there with small classes that are more spiritual as opposed to athletic. Those classes (in my experience) have very devoted students who come to yoga for the right reasons.

And Melinda on to your strap issue. Did you discuss with your teacher your injuries? And what pose did the teacher have you doing with the strap? Was it Supta Padangusthasana (reclined big toe pose)? To be honest, I can’t understand why the teacher did not give you an appropriate modification or another pose to do while the others were doing the pose with the strap. But with that being said, straps can be a very useful tool for those students who are tight or have certain restrictions. An example using the above mentioned pose: If a student has tight hamstrings and comes into the pose using their hands to lift the leg, they will likely pull their leg up to 90 degrees or close to it. BUT, the knee will be bent. This will not lengthen the hamstrings. Using a strap will allow you to back off the 90 degrees but keep a straight leg, thereby giving you a better stretch of the hams. A strap or any prop is not meant to take you past your normal limits, but to get you to where you will benefit from the pose. A good teacher will know their students limitations/injuries and provide variations/modifications, with or without props. As I was not privy to what occurred in the class, I can only guess.

And perhaps Melinda, vinyasa flow is not the style for you. Have you tried other classes with other teachers? Not knowing the extent of your injuries, a yoga therapy class or a more traditional hatha class might serve you better.

Looking forward to your response.

I begun my practice in Nepal and the Yoga did not have a name. It was part of an Ayurvedic Retreat. I think, looking back, that it was Hatha Yoga. Since then I have tried Bikram Yoga in Beligium Royal Yoga in Thailand and now Vinyasa Flow yoga. My main place for Practice is my Home in the early morning.
The Bikram classes were horrific. I was being shouted at for 90 mins and advanced students were incouraged to show us how it should be done with much applause that followed. This I feel interupted the flow of the calss and created barriers. During one ot the Vinyasa classes the floor was wet and very slippery due to the intense heat and a lady was kicked in the head during a posture because the class over populated. She was not badly hurt but it was a bit disturbing.

The reason I started this discussion was to find out how many people see what I see that has happened to Yoga in the last 20 years. I have always been lead to believe that Yoga Practice was about being calm and not pushing your body past it’s natural limits. That going towards the posture is the point and after some time and practice you may or may not manage the full posture. My views on straps and props are comming from this view.
I have been practicing Yoga for many years but 2 year ago was hit by a Motorbike as a pedestrian. My pelvis was broken in 4 places and I suffered a fracture to my Scarum and my knees were bashed, burnt and numb.
Its only now that I am looking for good class after being away for 2 years that I see how commercial Yoga Classes have become and the word Calm seems to have been replaced with Power.
Comments would be appreciated.
Namaste

Melinda,

Is it only comments you want or dialogue? No disrespect intended, but my response was more in line with answering questions and opening up some dialogue. If it is mere comments you want, disregard all but my first paragraph.

Namaste to you as well.

Oye, these modern times!

I live near a city of one million. There are dozens of authentic studios where yoga is practiced genuinely and with honest intent. There are also a bunch of other stuff here, but I don’t pay much attention to those anymore.

Hi Lotus Girl.
No problem. Comments or Discusion its all ok with me.
I will continue to look out for a good class becuase it’s nice to be with poelple of like mind.
:slight_smile:

Melinda2012: Were you “asked” to leave the class because you addressed the issue with your body and avoiding the straps or did you “leave” when you were told you had to use the straps?

Hi NBY

I siad that i didn’t like using straps and would I have to use them and she said that in her class I would be required to.
The point is that I should probably been clearer regaridng my limitations. I’m a bit bummed out I suppose that my body is presenting me with these limitations. I’m begining to realising that perhaps I’ll never get to the level of mobility that I used to have. There is a positive side to my story. The surgeon that monitored my condition said that if I hadn’t been as flexible as I was my injuries could have been a lot worse that means that Yoga is very benificial is ways that we don’t realise until we are faced with situations that we could never predict. I thank the universe and Yoga that I’m not in a wheelchair or worse.
Namaste