Bad Experience With Yoga Class- What To Do?

I’m a new member to this forum, and I hope that a kind soul or two here can help shed some light on this negative experience I’ve just had.

About three years ago, I was in a serious car accident that resulted in multiple serious injuries- one of them being a broken leg and torn meniscus. Since my second surgery a year ago, I have vastly recovered, but there is still damage that limits me on occasion.

Since a couple months ago, I’ve been attending yoga classes at a studio I can walk to about two or three times a week. It’s been ten years since I’ve done yoga, but I’m definitely remembering where I left off in my practice, and it’s an immensely positive experience, except for something that just happened.

One of the things I love about yoga and my studio is the message that all the teachers send: that it’s not a competition, that wherever you are in your practice is fine, to draw the line between pushing yourself to go further and pushing yourself too far, etc.

I’d only been in this teacher’s class twice before, but both times I really enjoyed the challenge she presented. I was going through practice when I felt a stress in my knee, and made a note not to push myself in any way that could potentially cause another injury.

Class went on, and we went to practice headstands (a pose that I’m uncertain at best with)- the way this teacher teaches them is to “kick” up- even though the leg I could use to kick up could be my good leg, and I could be near a wall, I knew that I could potentially have to catch myself falling the other way with both my legs hitting the floor- and possibly injuring my knee. So, I decided not to try to go up unless I felt secure in my strength; I just practiced with one leg up, one toe on the ground, and then switched.

Everyone else in the class could do the pose (some unsteadily, some better)- not a problem, except the teacher didn’t notice that I wasn’t completing the pose, and tried to gather everyone in a straight line so she could take a picture with her cell phone of everyone in her yoga class doing a headstand.

She did this without asking if it was okay with students to have their pictures taken, but instead starting telling us to rearrange our mats so we could be in a straight line near the wall for the picture. I was faced with either forcing myself into the pose or explaining that I couldn’t do it.

This was very upsetting to me- I stopped telling teachers after the first class that I have a past knee injury because it was never relevant and I don’t wish to discuss my accident if I don’t need to- I just modify poses that don’t work for me- and this is rare. We’re always given the option of stepping instead of jumping into certain poses, and usually that’s the only modification I need to do. Because of the philosophy that was presented to me, I really never imagined that I’d be in this sort of position when it came to yoga.

I stepped out, and said I hated having my picture taken. She continued to pose everyone, and I just got so upset that I left the class before it ended as quickly as possible and walked home without saying anything.

I don’t think she’s a bad person or even a bad teacher- the last class of hers I took, I even went up to her to tell her how much I enjoyed it.

But I don’t know what to do next. I can avoid her classes or try to find another studio entirely; my boyfriend thinks I should talk to her (and that perhaps it could help her as well as me to do so), and I know he’s probably right, but I’m unsure of how to do this productively. I just don’t know why she’d think acting like that would be okay, and at the same time I just don’t want to make her feel bad.

Even a sentence or two would be appreciated. Thank you for reading all of this.

Communication with your teacher is key here I would say. Definitely talk to her and see if you can just let her know it made you feel uncomfortable. If she is truly willing to hear her students critique or concerns she will be okay with hearing you are not comfortable with having your picture taken without asking.

Nicole,

Here are my thoughts though I’d stress there’s no one “correct” answer.

First, as a teacher of yoga I do not have the right to photograph students without a written release to use their image. That is simply a matter of respect.

Second, I would not facilitate a photo session unless it had been stipulated well in advance and all attendees agreed to participate.

When students are in Sirsasana (headstand) they are bearing weight on their head (how much is another discussion) and should be carefully watched by the teacher without fail.

Lastly, as a teacher of yoga I go to great lengths to express and maintain my respect for students. This respect means not placing them in positions of embarrassment or belittlement. This also means that sometimes students may feel these things even with my best efforts as we are all human and I have yet to meet a practitioner of yoga who doesn’t have some thing to work on or out - including feeling embarrassed or belittled.

These four things conjoin to make up what I feel is appropriate behavior for me as a student and teacher of yoga. Howeverrrrrrr…

This isn’t everyone’s position.

As for recourse I believe it’s completely “okay” to have a chat with the teacher outlining your feelings or with the studio director. It may also be that you choose a different teacher. Not all teachers are for all students AND not all students are for all teachers.

I would further point out that these sort of things are never about being a bad person. However a sound teacher doesn’t photograph students in Sirsasana unless it’s prearranged with advanced students who can all do the pose over a period of time - safely. Someone who is kind and compassionate is called a human being. Someone who conveys yoga to others with effect and safety, that person is a yoga teacher.

The teacher is totally out of order to take photos without asking…and it is not appropriate to take photos during class…she should have told the class that she wanted some pics and asked if any students wish to stay after class for a photo session.

I agree with Gordon…it could be unsafe to take a photo of someone in headstand if they have not been warned…someone could be taken by surprise and fall over…( I would be very shocked and surprised if it happened in a class)
Also kicking into a headstand can be unsafe…there are safer more controlled ways to do headstand…and the more controlled the assent the safer you will be and the less likely you are to fall.

Gordon also says–I would further point out that these sort of things are never about being a bad person. However a sound teacher doesn’t photograph students in Sirsasana unless it’s prearranged with advanced students who can all do the pose over a period of time - safely. Someone who is kind and compassionate is called a human being. Someone who conveys yoga to others with effect and safety, that person is a yoga teacher. - Total agreement here!

I would email/write or speak to a manager at the yoga school and tell them what happened and how you feel…or speak to the teacher directly if you are comfortable to do so…and if you do generally enjoy her classes then give her another chance…but do remind her that you have an issue with your knee…but you know how to modify/take care of your self during class.
And if you notice other occasions where your teacher appears not to be paying attention to the students in some…stop going.

A

First of all congratulations on having the courage to step away from a situation you felt uncomfortable and maybe a little unsafe approaching.

Life is going to be full of implied consent moments that we have to be able to roll with and be adult enough to make the right choices for ourselves and others. It’s life.

The teacher asked everyone to line up to get their pictures taken. Well that is your cue to step out and you did. Good for you.

Is it terrible that she didn’t ask you specifically?
This reads like an excited teacher calling a [B]let’s go to the party[/B] moment.
Obviously thrilled enough[B] with the [B]entire[/B] class[/B]’ effort that she wanted a memento. Is that so terrible? Well if it is good luck with that reactiveness these camera phones are everywhere these days.

Were you selected out? Doesn’t sound like it. Nope reads like she was happy with you too. Will the picture show you not getting the pose?
Nope it will just show you in a position approaching the pose. A moment stopped in time. Will it be perfect? That is one for the sages.
There will always be the few who react. [B]Well I wasn’t asked. Well no but you were invited. [/B]You chose not to go. Good for you.

Heal swiftly and be well enough.

Anyone find it the least bit odd that a yoga teacher has her/his cell phone in the teaching space?

Yes very!!!

(mine is in the room just because of issues with theft…there is no where safe for me to leave it…but it is OFF!!)

I did attend some classes here in Phnom Penh at a gym and at a hotel and the teacher not only read an SMS but answered it!!! while teaching!!!
and this happened in more than one class…and in one class she did it TWICE…

At NataRaj Yoga none or our teachers EVER use their phones during class whether they are teaching at our studio or out at other venues…and if I here that they do…I may just fire them…clients are also asked to switch off phones during class…which they all do with no complaint.

(I also teach out at some hotels and no matter how many times I ask…clients still leave phones on and will answer them during class…there seems to be something about wealthy Khmer people…cannot force them…)

[QUOTE=InnerAthlete;65102]Anyone find it the least bit odd that a yoga teacher has her/his cell phone in the teaching space?[/QUOTE]

A little off topic:
Odd for the instructor yes however consider if a large percentage of the class is mothers with young children who don?t feel comfortable being out of touch for emergencies perhaps cell phones may be justifiable? Considering classes are more of an instructional environment i.e. breaks/pauses for explanation/examples, different than one?s personal practice. Also there is the unusual circumstance, say a family member is on their deathbed or such that the instructor or student needs to be available? I?m writing this because I do allow people to keep their cell phones on if they feel it important? I certainly would not allow cameras unless everyone agrees.

I am sorry I have not read everyones reply, perhaps they have already said this, but all I can say, in order to follow what the experience might be trying to teach you… is to practice Compassion to yourself and to the teacher…
Peace and love…
XII

[QUOTE=InnerAthlete;65102]Anyone find it the least bit odd that a yoga teacher has her/his cell phone in the teaching space?[/QUOTE]

Not at all in this communication age.
Phone apps to que music/ time poses/ and in this case take pictures of students.

One may react to it while another might want a journal baseline or reference for how they approach a pose.

And lets face it there is no anonymity anymore.

I still remember the very moment when a flash brought me to this awareness and out of an end of the yoga show group yoga trance dance as I realized that I had now been captured for the ages. Photo recognition and my students and employers might see my over expressive free dancing and think/judge/react to it.
People at my work have been let go for expressive partner dancing outside work that made it to social media what fate for me and my expressive non-substance dance but maybe looks like a substance induced dance?..

Changing world

I just want to thank everyone for the time they took to respond to my post. I will probably avoid this teacher in the future; I don’t think that she is a good fit for me in terms of attitude and teaching style.

I too have bad experience but that was with my body . . . :slight_smile:
I feel pain in my legs the whole day after my first yoga class :slight_smile:

[QUOTE=justnicole;65127]I just want to thank everyone for the time they took to respond to my post. I will probably avoid this teacher in the future; I don’t think that she is a good fit for me in terms of attitude and teaching style.[/QUOTE]

You also mentioned that you did not believe that she was a [I]?bad person or even a bad teacher?.[/I]

For this reason I would question your avoidance…what exactly are you avoiding? For example,

1.[B] trust [/B]is broken and you no longer feel [B]safe[/B] with the teacher
2. you are afraid of the headstand (it is difficult because it takes much [B]confidence[/B] at the beginning)
3. your ego has been injured and thus avoidance is also avoiding feelings of [B]insecurity[/B]
4. because your knee was already hurting the situation heightened this and perhaps brought back [B]memories [/B]of your accident and ongoing physical injury, which I know can be very [B]debilitating and upsetting[/B]!

The list goes on…questioning is important, you have had a strong reaction, you can use this to go within and explore yourself.

Nurture yourself xx

I just feel like that is such a weird scenario. Yoga isn’t about showing off and taking pictures. It would honestly mess up my flow and concentration to have my picture taken during yoga practice. That is something that should be done after class for sure. I would bring it up with the teacher because maybe she wasn’t aware of how her “photo shoot” came across. It is also possible that other students felt uncomfortable and wanted to say something but didn’t have the nerve.

Also, it is not about being a “bad” person. For instance, if someone accidentally backs up and starts standing on your foot then you say something to them. They aren’t a “bad” person for it; they just weren’t aware that they were standing on you. Maybe the teacher wasn’t aware as how her actions came across.

[QUOTE=InnerAthlete;65102]Anyone find it the least bit odd that a yoga teacher has her/his cell phone in the teaching space?[/QUOTE]

That would be completely out of line.

[QUOTE=InnerAthlete;65102]Anyone find it the least bit odd that a yoga teacher has her/his cell phone in the teaching space?[/QUOTE]

I prop my phone up in my area to display a countown timer because often when teaching I have found that there is not a highly visible clock where I am, and that I have absolutely [B]no[/B] sense of the passage of time. :).

Start Learning from experts. We are at Arhanta yoga provide yoga classes from experts at an affordable price do visit our website and know more details.