InnerAthlete, I hear what you are saying. From personal experience, I have lost weight while doing yoga, but I do it twice a day, and I am very careful what I eat. Plus I am still active outside of yoga.
I do think Yoga does help keep you focused on your health, and your body, and in return, helps you eat better, and be an overall happier well balanced person. I guess it depends on how serious someone is when they are doing Yoga. But either way, Yoga does not have to be serious, or have anything to do with weight loss. If you are doing Yoga, you should notice a difference in mental, and physical body.
Thanks for your point of view!
www.hippiepower.com