[QUOTE=Triston;85064]ray:
There is always the relative and ultimate reality pov in these kinds of spiritual discussions.
Relative:
concept of reincarnation, remember past lives, spiritual progress continues from past lives, etc
Absolute:
What you quote above. That there is no reincarnation, no spiritual progress, no I, etc
And teachers like Ramana and Nis would switch between the two all the time.
For example, one seeker asks Nis if he can sing a bhajan for him, and he happily agrees.
On another day, the same request could be met with a “who wants to sing to who” kind of pointing.[/QUOTE]
There’s not a notion in human consciousness outside the realm of ignorance (including this one) yet we contemplate the indescribable because it’s blissful to even discuss. They were both very clear and constant on the concept of rebirth, the bidis chain smoker who’s human apparatus expired of throat cancer “N” himself said habits are of the mind/body (bhajan, smoking). Forget two dead brown guys form India the answer is obvious upon examination and within you.
Q: I see you living your life according to a pattern. You run a meditation class in the morning, lecture and have discussions regularly; twice daily there is worship (puja) and religious singing (bhajan) in the evening. You seem to adhere to the routine scrupulously.
M: The worship and the singing are as I found them and I saw no reason to interfere. The general routine is according to the wishes of the people with whom I happen to live or who come to listen. They are working people, with many obligations and the timings are for their convenience. Some repetitive routine is inevitable. Even animals and plants have their time-tables.
Q: You smoke?
M: My body kept a few habits which may as well continue till it dies. There is
no harm in them.
Q: You eat meat?
M: I was born among meat-eating people and my children are eating meat. I eat very little – and make no fuss.
Q: Meat-eating implies killing.
M: Obviously. I make no claims of consistency. You think absolute consistency is possible; prove it by example. Don’t preach what you do not practice.