Which style?

Hello all,

I am searching for a yoga class to help my girlfriend with her anxiety breathing issues. She feels as though she is “unable to get a breath” and is constantly sighing and heaving her cheast and shoulders when an episode occurs.

I am hoping to find a yoga class to-
A) Teach her breathing techniques to combat the problem when it arises
B) Help her with stress relief to reduce the number of episode that occur

My girlfriend has participated in Bikram yoga previously but found that she was constantly getting run down and ill after each session.
So i have been searching for a new yoga form for her- My problam is that I am overwhelmed by the vast array of styles and courses out there and I do not know which yoga style is the most appropriate!

A college suggested Hatha yoga.

ANy suggestions from “The experts” would be greatly appreciated!

I’ll presume in my response that your GF is also searching, otherwise the efficacy of whatever you find will be greatly diminished.

The physical practice of postures (asanas) usually qualifies a practice as a Hatha yoga practice. With that in mind, one can see how a directive toward Hatha is incredibly broad and not particularly helpful.

There are two important things to consider. The first is that a healing protocol must be comprehensive. If the practice offers only physical postures and some breathing it is nice, it is helpful, it feels good, but it is incomplete (as a healing), just as a band-aid or an ice pack are incomplete.

The second thing is that some of these physical practices are static, thus forcing the student to adapt to the practice, while others are malleable and adapt to to the student. Forcing the human being to fit the practice makes so little sense to me I can’t even fathom how it is defensible. It is the yoga that should shape itself to the current nature of the student - the suppleness and stiffness, the well being and the illness, the rigidity and the openness.

The three practices that I feel have powerful haling abilities - above and beyond feel good, nice, and helpful are Viniyoga, Iyengar, and Purna Yoga (the expression of yoga that I practice, train and teach).

smac,

All yoga is hatha as far as she might be concerned, that is postures and breathing, even Bikram. so her search may go on until she finds a comfortable balance of postures and breathing which vary with style, name and teacher. The teacher will be more important than the particular style.

In the meantime, she has to learn that she can only get as much breath in has she has first pushed out: she has to first make room. When she’s having an “episode,” where she feels she can’t get a breath, encourage her to exhale forcefully and completely through her nose, to press it all out until she is empty. What happens next is natural; a comfortable, relaxed breath. That’s yoga 101 by any name.

good luck,
siva

Smac,
I did a little googling (only a little) and found that a lot of people who have this sensation of a shortness of breath like your friend has are experiencing anxiety. Sometimes the awareness of anxiety comes AFTER the sensation of a shortness of breath, so the person doesn’t connect it as the cause.
I think it would be fantastic for your friend to learn some pranayama that will help her when she feels an episode coming on. She can then take control of her breathing. Practicing pranayama helped me learn to not be alarmed when I felt the need for breath - as in those exercises when one breathes the air out completely, then holds it out for as long as they possibly can. The body fights to bring air in, but you resist, and eventually you can hold the air out with a calmness, even when the body is crying out “I need air!”. It is wonderful to have that sense of calm control.
Remember, the worst thing that can happen if you hold it out too long is you can pass out, then you start to breathe again. lol.

I am very familiar with breathing issues, both real and psychosomatic (which can be no less serious). I had asthma and upper respiratory problems for a long time until I was put on Advair (a steroid inhaler) for four years during which time my breathing and health was better but I had side effects and long term negative impacts on my health. When I decided to go off it for good my kidneys started producing too much mucous and I had chronic bronchitis and pneumonia for an entire year. Part of the solution for me was the drastically alter my diet in order to make things as easy as possible for my system to process without generating mucous until my body could recover from the effects of the steroids. But also essential was a more determined, resolute, and fearless attitude to being healthy and life in general.

The biggest key for breathing problems is to maintain natural breathing patterns. When a person suffers from a breathing problem regularly, they are likely to worry about it, and be on the look out for it. Then when anything does occur they immediately focus their mind on it, disrupting natural breathing. In this situation every breath becomes willfull and controlled by the conscious mind. This type of unnatural breathing causes a shortness of breath and increased tension. This in turn can cause even more anxiety and create a cyclical pattern. The person needs to just let go and breath naturally but this is not as easy as flipping a light switch.

As you said, the long-term key is to get to a point where you are no longer worried about your breathing, so that your mind will not be focusing on it, and your breathing can remain subconscious and natural even in times that would normally cause worry and anxiety.

Remaining busy and engaged will help in this. When the mind is preoccupied with other things then it cannot be so focused on worrying about breathing. Often times people say they are too busy to get sick, and there is alot of truth to that. Idle time is the worst enemy of someone with alot of anxiety. Activities do not have to be physically demanding, as long as they are engaging and constructive. Things that involve responsibility are best, such as business, work, volunteering, cooking, housework, taking care of children or family, etc. When you are worrying about the needs of others you have less time to worry about yourself. Owning a dog is also good, because it gets you outside for walks in the fresh air and sunlight and they keep you light hearted.

Making some sort of change to your diet, habits, or schedule is also good. For me when I changed my diet it was something to feel reassured about, in the way that the mind says ?I did this, so I’ll be fine?. Something like quitting smoking, eating less red meat, going to bed earlier and on a more regular schedule, cutting out sugar, not snacking, etc. All of those types of things will not only help with overall health and reduce stress on the body, but they are also something to fall back on and take reassurance from. It helps you feel like you have earned your improved health or breathing, which in turn increases confidence and decreases anxiety.

Yoga practice is also very beneficial. As for choosing a style, they are just based on the way a particular person sequenced and grouped the postures they emphasized and what guidelines they recommend. Hatha Yoga technically means any physical Yoga. I would recommend finding someone with obviously radiant good health and a happy demeanor. Clearly what they are doing works, and being around them will allow their care-free attitude to rub off. If going to classes wears you out, then try something where you are going at a slower pace, stopping to re-group between postures. Perhaps a DVD or something where you can stop and start as you please with no pressure. Maybe someone on here can recommend helpful DVDs. Don’t try alot of pranayam until you have first built up some lung strength through asanas first, otherwise it will just wear you out.

Some students find it very hard to adapt to the high temperature in the Bikram style. The amount of oxygen in a closed hot room, decreases considerablly. Thus, it’s common for a new practicioner to feel “short of breath” with that practice.

I can think of a couple of options:

  • Gentle Yoga
  • Yoga for beginners (also known as “foundations”)

Another option is to find a studio that has a specific “pranayama” practice. Pranayama is the focus on breathing techniques. Once she understands this essential technique, I think she will find it easier to practice yoga at regular temperature.

Regardles of the style, I think she shall not practice in a room with high (about 80’) temperature. Once her cardiovascular capacity has improved, then she can try hot yoga practice again, but this shall be a 2nd phase.

My 2 cents

[QUOTE=smac;45687]Hello all,

I am searching for a yoga class to help my girlfriend with her anxiety breathing issues. She feels as though she is “unable to get a breath” and is constantly sighing and heaving her cheast and shoulders when an episode occurs.

I am hoping to find a yoga class to-
A) Teach her breathing techniques to combat the problem when it arises
B) Help her with stress relief to reduce the number of episode that occur

ANy suggestions from “The experts” would be greatly appreciated![/QUOTE]

I’d recommend any suitable Hatha yoga style + Yoga Nidra
and tell her that she is beautiful few times a day:) that is the best thing for stress

and tell her that she is beautiful few times a day that is the best thing for stress

I have to agree with CityMonk. :slight_smile:
Find sincere ways to express your appreciation of her as a person. We are never told enough when we are appreciated, or when someone has a warm thought toward us because of something we said or did. It should be expressed more, and relieves VERY MUCH stress.

[QUOTE=siva;45693]smac,
In the meantime, she has to learn that she can only get as much breath in has she has first pushed out: she has to first make room. When she’s having an “episode,” where she feels she can’t get a breath, encourage her to exhale forcefully and completely through her nose, to press it all out until she is empty. What happens next is natural; a comfortable, relaxed breath. That’s yoga 101 by any name.

good luck,
siva[/QUOTE]
yeah, that is the interesting thing about a panic attic. when its happening by itself, meaning not consciously trying to breathe, the exhale is very short and the inhale is very long. when you watch it people try to consciously breathe, same thing
In the physiology of it it keeeps the stale air in the base of the lungs and that gets more toxic the longer it is there, not only is it not new oxygen, it actually becomes toxic.

foundations?

Some very good points made by InnerAthlete and CityMonk. Trying to look for a Yoga style to fit your GF’s needs will not help a lot. So a deeper understanding of a breathing process is needed first, before a given yoga practice can be adapted.

Irregular breathing is a symptom and not the cause. Breathing is nature’s gift to us as it runs like a ‘perpetual motion’. But, its components are closely linked with many other things.

Proper and full breathing is done with the chest as well as the diaphragm. Probably your GF has to stretch her shoulders due to a reduced or no diaphragm breathing ability. This happens mainly under stress and bad eating habits. Diaphragm divides the stomach between the lungs and the digestive organs. Accumulation of fat occurs primarily below the diaphragm and restricts its movement. That?s the reason why InnerAthlete is recommending more asanas to reduce stress and mobilize the breathing apparatus. Once this is achieved breathing exercises will not be stressful paving a way for even and deep breathing.

We have erroneously connected diet or eating only with weight-reduction, without ever thinking what brought that excess weight in the first place. Not just the calories, but we need to watch when we eat and how much. The American portion is suicidal. Similarly any fatty substance eaten after 4 pm is a burden on the digestion. Food eaten while watching TV is ill-digested. Different people have different body constitutions and the same food that suits one may not suit the other. Please remember that all this affects lower abdomen the flexibility of which is an important factor in proper breathing.

Hi guys Junaid here Yoga is a pasture in which we can adjust our body to be fit as we can, so we can’t find any style for yoga we just go to the yoga class and follow the yoga instructor. He will tell us the best the yoga style. At the start of my yoga classes i was confused how to take proper yoga style after few days my yoga instructor tell me not look to the style follow the instructor after that words i left all the things and following the instructor so i suggest you not look for style always follow your instructor.:stuck_out_tongue:

Actually Junaid, I’m going to disagree with you in that some “styles” (read: expressions) of yoga (read: asana) are harmful to the student, taught to students not ready for that level of teaching, and far too often taught by a teacher with only rudimentary training.

The skill a yoga student is wise to cultivate is the skill of discernment. In that way the student can determine what is appropriate for them at any given time based on their living and being.