[quote=CityMonk;30979]Well, but if one stays in the thoughtless state all the time we will not be able to communicate with the world and support the life of our bodies.
[/quote]
Or ,We will not be interfering with our natural state, which is best left uninterfered with, unaltered, unmodified.
If I will just witness and not doer, then who will cook the breakfast? who will bring the knowledge for my students, who going to donate money to the Children’s hospital, who will organize action for planting more trees in the city?, etc, etc
Let’s say there’s a divine intelligence in the Universe(some might call it God or Cosmic ordering principle, or whatever, for the sake of discussion) that we can discover through yogic sadhana that does what’s best for us ( “I” & everyone else)and will operate behind the scenes, as it were, if only we let it, by non-interference, and a couple of other dooing things-that we/the “I” does- i.e meditation,pranayam,asana ,yamas & niyamaa and so forth, that nudge us and help us along,move us towards that end.So we’re not taking a back seat and watching folk suffer but we are tackling at it’s root-which is roughly speaking changing the very perspective we have towards that suffering we perceive,are witnessing etc.
Thats ok. Yoga practice is not about only get thoughtless and sit in the beautiful garden meditating. Tell me if I’m wrong…
Yes but it’s a main one.The ceasing of the mind-control modifications, the eddies is a sign,so we are told, of expanded Consciousness.
Thoughts bind us to ignorance of illlusion;these prevent us from seeing our tue nature which manifests and arises, in fact is, pure(bliss) Conscousness uncorrupted by mental constructs-i.e thoughts, so we are told.(Patanjali and others)
So the suggestion is we can still act in the world, but without thinking, or planning. In fact because of t his it our behaviours and actions become morally self-regulated( and regulating).We act because of bigger interestsbecause wwe identify with ourselves less.We are told the “i” though is the biggest illusion of them, the illusion of separation as they say between I/us and everything else…
Lets say I will sit in meditation and practicing asanas, conneting with my true self… at the same time someone is dying in Africa because they simply did not had rainfall withing two years and all the water is gone, and there is no way to get a drop of water… lets assune that I have an ability to help…should I help OR SHOULD I JUST wait “until it will work it out”, until people will be dead from thirst?
Yeah help after you’ve finished meditating.There’s alot of folk that help for chairity but sometimes i wonder if they do that because they are either guilty or trying to make themsleves feel better-i.e their motives for ‘helping’ are not purely authentic or genuine. In my country,uk, you see touts that are quite well paid trying to ask for money for charities but i guess it’s better than nothing.
Well to go deeper in philosophy we can tell that death is the natural process and survival on this planet is not easy…ect…
One of life’s certainties, in some sense of the word.
I understand this, and agree. But can go with the flow… maybe need to learn…
No, i don’t think so.
Although , unlearnnig can be just as useful…if not more.So our vantage pt. is not courrpted by beliefs,language, thought structures etc.
I think the uggesstion is that ther may an intelligence we cannot see operating behind the scenes/material world our eyes can see.By giving ourselves upto that things can take care of themselves.That’s probably why prayer is like a kind of siddhi yoga.We give ourselves up the divine without e=any thought-processes,planning etc to get in the way.What is called the faith of spirituality or even religion could actually be the flow of Consciousness in it’s pur unadulterated state. So we act in the world.We live in the her & now rather than think it.Kashmir shaivists will say that thinking is at the root of human suffering.Try it for one day and you will see how alot of previous baggage that epeople rouitnely carry around all day, the way folk react to others and so on- see how much more stress-free your life is.
What i am saying is that life can take care of itself sometimes if we give up seeking to contorl it or be motivated by what we/ the “I” gets out of it.When you act for the interests of the world in whatever way you find possible then the “i” drops more in to the background.
So you can be saving little black kids from Africa like Madonna but also be actively working to change your perspective on how you view injustice,suffering etc in the world.
I remember a saddhu coming back from the kumbh mela festival in india (pictured on uk tv) say to some itinerant spiritual seeker who was doing a series- (whether he did all eight limbs or not i’m not enitrely sure but he smoked the ganja and did some asana)- he said yoga does not (necessarily) end suffering ( although i think it can do that) but can help us to understand it ( better).