[QUOTE=Suhas Tambe;33647]SuryaDeva,
I know little about Patanjali.
Your Quote: Patanjali very explicitly mentions them as being another valid way to reach supersensible realities and attain psychic powers:
4.1 Psychic powers arise by birth, drugs, mantras, purificatory acts and austerity(tapas or sadana)
In other words you can be born with knowledge and powers of supersensory things. If not, you can also attain them through drugs, mantras, some kind of kriya yoga(cleanses the pranic system and activates the kundalini) or through pure sadana.
It is a wrong and misleading translation. Secondly, Patanjali has written “sutras” that means “thread”, so context has great significance and you cannot take one sutra and interprete in isolation.
Though the effect of these five things may be apparently similar, there is tremendous difference in terms of the goal of Yoga, enlightenment. When powers arise by birth, it is not accidental. It is a legacy of previous births in which the powers were acquired through spiritual practices. This is obvious in the fact that such powers survive death. In comparison, the so called power of drugs vanishes the moment the change-agent is gone. Secondly, unlike the spiritual progress that accumulates in a positive way, drugs produce harmful side effects, ultimately destroying the same bodies (physical-astral and causal) that take you to enlightenment. Though not as harmful as drugs, mantras, penance and austerities have similar limitation of not being able to permanently transform the yogi.
These five agents of similar effects are mentioned by Patanjali in comparison to highlight and distinguish the cell-level changes that eight-fold Yoga path brings about. These changes are positive and ireversible. Hope you agree.[/QUOTE]
ERGO!!! Samadhi being a lasting means and yoga proper?
I’m not sure on that statement “positive and ireversible” though…
Just in theory>… Let’s say there was a person who through their mastery of Samadhi Achieved curious abilities, could do miracles like it was the play of a child, had complete realization . . . this person was Frollicking in Maya.
Lets say this person made a vow to let the good mother place them wherever she wanted to place them … within reason, in any manner … so that they could play a positive role in the world on down the line. They willingly fashion a golden chain of Karma.
They get a little vactation.
The time is ripe and off they go to the material plane.
But none of their attainments are intact because this would not be in keeping with the original vow.
So I think the Karma trumps all . . .